Practical hiring guide

Weak candidate or weak evidence?

A decision tree for telling the difference between a criterion not being demonstrated and an assessment process that did not test it well.

Updated 25 September 2026 · 6 minute guide

Do not treat an untested criterion as a failed criterion

A short or unclear answer can mean several different things. The candidate may not have the capability, may not have understood the question, or may not have had a fair opportunity to show relevant experience. The next step depends on which situation you have.

The decision tree

1. Was the criterion defined?

If no, pause. Write the role-relevant criterion and the observable indicators before evaluating the answer.

2. Was there a valid opportunity to demonstrate it?

Check the question, format, accessibility and context. If the opportunity was poor, label the information missing rather than negative.

3. Is the answer specific enough to inspect?

Separate a concrete observation from a general impression. Ask one focused probe about context, action, reasoning or result.

4. Do sources agree?

If interviewers or work samples conflict, record the conflict and compare the sources. Do not silently choose the most convenient version.

5. Is the remaining information sufficient for this decision?

If yes, the accountable human owner records the rationale and uncertainty. If no, choose a proportionate next step or stop the process.

Three common misclassifications

What happenedDo not concludeRecord instead
The interviewer skipped the core question“The candidate lacks the skill.”Missing information; plan a fair follow-up.
A candidate gave a concrete example but reviewers disagree on its relevance“One reviewer is simply wrong.”Conflicting interpretation; return to the criterion and source.
The answer is vague after a focused probe“The person can never do this work.”Limited evidence for this assessment; document the boundary of the observation.

The question to carry into the debrief

“What did this process allow us to learn, and what did it leave untested?”

This framework helps a team describe uncertainty. It does not determine candidate quality or replace the accountable hiring decision.