Practical hiring guide

Strong, weak, missing or conflicting information

A practical way to label interview information before it becomes a hiring judgement.

Updated 25 September 2026 · 6 minute guide

A label is not a verdict

Teams move faster when they agree what kind of information they have before arguing about what it means. These four labels keep the boundary visible between an observation and a decision.

Four useful labels

Strong

Specific, relevant and sufficiently detailed for the criterion. The source and context are clear.

“In the migration example, the candidate described the trade-off, the chosen approach and the measured outcome.”

Weak

Some relevant material is present, but important detail or reasoning is absent.

“The candidate described the task but not how options were compared or what changed afterwards.”

Missing

The process did not produce usable information. The question may not have been asked, understood or accessible.

“No observation is available for stakeholder communication.”

Conflicting

Two sources or reviewers describe the same criterion differently and the difference matters.

“The work sample suggests one approach; the follow-up discussion suggests another. Reconcile the sources.”

Use one criterion to practise

Take “explains technical trade-offs to a non-specialist audience.” For each interview source, note the audience, options, reasoning and result. If one field is absent, record the gap; do not fill it with a personality impression.

Follow-up prompts

  • Who needed the explanation, and what did they need to decide?
  • Which alternatives did you consider?
  • What changed after the explanation?
  • What would you want to verify before making the decision?

A debrief rule

Strong information can support a judgement; weak information can guide a focused follow-up; missing information can set a stopping condition; conflicting information can trigger reconciliation. None of the labels makes the final decision automatically.

Use the labels consistently across a role, and keep the original source available to the reviewer who owns the decision.